|
|
|
|
by Editor Ralph Scylla
Edited and published by Yvette Depaepe, the 18th of November 2026
Seven photographs, seven songs, and a few things I never quite managed to say.
“analog dinner” by Teruhiko Tsuchida
I belong to a generation that expressed romantic feelings by sitting in front of a radio with one finger on the record button.
For hours.
We waited for the right song, hoping the DJ wouldn’t talk over the introduction or, even worse, the ending. We recorded it onto a cassette, rewound it, listened to it, and occasionally discovered that we’d recorded the weather forecast as well.
Then we did it all over again.
Making a mixtape was a serious business. The order of the songs mattered. The opening track had to be perfect. The final song had to say something profound, preferably something we were far too embarrassed to say ourselves.
We wrote the titles on the little cardboard insert, sometimes decorated the cover, and eventually presented our masterpiece to the woman of our dreams.
With trembling hands.
It was, essentially, a declaration of love disguised as a collection of other people’s songs.
Unfortunately, the woman of our dreams didn’t always share our enthusiasm. I suspect some of my most carefully assembled mixtapes ended up in drawers, never to be heard again. Others may have been recorded over with something more useful. The weather forecast, perhaps.
You might think I would have learned my lesson.
Apparently not.
Many years later, I made another musical compilation, this time for my daughter Hannah. No cassette, no radio, no trembling hands. Just a playlist.
Whether she ever listened to it is another question.
But I’ll come back to that.
I’ve paired seven photographs from 1x with seven pieces of music that came to mind while looking at them. Think of it as a mixtape you can start anywhere.
“ARCTIC SILENCE 15” by Patrick Ems
Song: Ryuichi Sakamoto · Bibo no Aozora
Music and images have been keeping each other company for a very long time. Think of the helicopters approaching to the sound of Wagner’s Ride of the Valkyries in Apocalypse Now. Or Louis Armstrong singing What a Wonderful World while Good Morning, Vietnam shows us images of war and destruction.
For me, Underworld’s Born Slippy .NUXX will probably always belong to Trainspotting. I only have to hear the opening notes and the film starts playing somewhere inside my head.
“Another Brick in the Wall” by Carmine Chiriacò
Song: Underworld · Born Slippy .NUXX
In a film, someone has chosen the music for us. But occasionally I look at a photograph, and a particular song simply appears in my mind.
I don’t choose it. It just arrives.
A portrait might remind me of Tom Waits. An empty street might bring back a song I haven’t heard in thirty years. Sometimes the connection is obvious. Sometimes it makes absolutely no sense.
A photograph is never quite the same for two people. The photographer brings something to the picture. The viewer brings something too. And sometimes, without warning, we bring an entire record collection.
“old harburg bridge” by Alexander Schönberg
Song: Nick Drake · River Man
My friend Steven, who kindly read an earlier version of this article, raised a thoughtful objection. Associating a photograph with a particular song, he suggested, might interfere with the viewer’s own interpretation.
He has a point. A photograph should be able to stand on its own, and a song that means everything to one person may mean absolutely nothing to someone else.
“Barge haulers” by Victoria Ivanova (Glinka)
Song: Tom Waits · Take It with Me
These pairings say something about how I see the photographs. They probably reveal considerably more about me.
I have occasionally used lines from songs as titles for my own photographs. Some people may recognise the reference. Others may discover something entirely different. Or they may simply conclude that I’ve chosen a ridiculous title.
All three possibilities seem perfectly reasonable.
“Grief” by Ton Dirven
Song: Max Richter · On the Nature of Daylight
Sometimes I simply don’t know why a particular photograph reminds me of a particular song. And I rather like leaving that a mystery.
So I shall leave the photographs and the music alone together. They can sort things out between themselves.
Perhaps one of these photographs will remind you of a song I’ve never heard. Perhaps one of the songs will bring back a memory that has nothing whatsoever to do with my own.
That would be wonderful.
“Mad Madrid” by Alejandro Marcos
Song: Joni Mitchell · Both Sides, Now (2000 orchestral version)
So, about that playlist.
I made it for Hannah out of songs that had accompanied me through different parts of my life. Some remind me of people, some of places, some of moments I’d happily experience again. Others remind me of things I’d rather forget.
I suppose it was another attempt to explain myself through music. A rather long musical letter, assembled from songs written by people who were considerably better at expressing themselves than I am.
I don’t think she’s ever listened to it. Which, considering my earlier experiences with mixtapes, suggests a certain consistency in my life.
But the playlist still exists.
“waiting” by Tatsuo Suzuki
Song: Fred again.. · Kyle (Northern Line)
And if you can make a better mixtape, please send it to Hannah...
![]() | Write |
| Mike Kreiten CREW Very interesting article, Ralph. Reminds me of our common friend Steven's comments. Since you engage in the Critique forum quite intensely, I think it's a missed chance to refer to photography as a source for emotions, either recall or even receive some without knowing the scene from other's work. If a photo can convey emotions, it's usually good. No matter if just a mood, a smile, envy, desire. |
![]() | Ralph Scylla CREW Hi Mike,
Yes, I can certainly relate to your point about envy. There are quite a few photographs out there that make me positively green with envy!
First of all, thank you very much for your comment. And please forgive me for occasionally trespassing on your territory in the Critique Forum. We've talked about this before, of course, and you did say I was welcome to contribute my two cents from time to time.
And naturally, you're absolutely right: photography is a source of emotion. In fact, I think that is precisely what makes both curation and photographic criticism so incredibly difficult.
How many technically perfect photographs do we see every day that ultimately leave us completely indifferent? That, I must admit, is one of my greatest difficulties when judging photographs.
I might look at an architectural photograph and genuinely admire the amount of work that has gone into it. Someone may have spent three hours correcting converging verticals, carefully refining the tonal variations of the concrete, and making sure every last detail is absolutely perfect. I look at the result and think: Good heavens, what dedication! What technical brilliance! What impeccable craftsmanship!
And yet the photograph does absolutely nothing for me. Nothing at all.
Then I come across a blurred black-and-white photograph of a woman standing beneath a shower, perhaps photographed in deep, low-key lighting, perhaps not even particularly accomplished technically – and suddenly, there is an emotion. An atmosphere, a suggestion of a story, something that reaches me immediately.
Or take the very first photograph in my article, *Analog Dinner*. It instantly takes me back to the days when we fiddled about with music cassettes, painstakingly wound unruly tape back into its casing, and tried to splice broken lengths together. If you remember those delightful little exercises, you'll also remember that they were not particularly delightful at the time! And yet that one photograph brings back an entire world of memories.
Perhaps that is the essential difference between a photograph whose craftsmanship I admire and one that genuinely moves me.
So yes, I agree with you: the ability to evoke an emotional response is, to my mind, an essential ingredient of a truly good photograph. Although that leads us to a rather sobering conclusion: perhaps there aren't quite as many truly good photographs as we like to think.
Incidentally, I'm currently working on another article, this time about the overinterpretation of photographs. And while thinking about it, I noticed something rather peculiar: laughter seems to be virtually forbidden in fine-art nude photography.
Now, I certainly haven't examined every nude photograph under the sun, but I've looked at a fair few. Melancholy, longing, vulnerability, loneliness, desire, suffering – all perfectly acceptable. But a genuine, uninhibited laugh somehow seems to be incompatible with the prevailing aesthetic.
Why on earth should that be? Why is a naked person apparently allowed to express almost every conceivable emotion except sheer, unselfconscious joy?
I find that rather a pity. And perhaps it's another example of just how much our ideas of what constitutes 'good' photography are shaped by convention.
In any case, thank you for setting me thinking. As you can see, your comment has sent me off on quite a few tangents already. And that is precisely why I enjoy our exchanges so much! |
![]() | Mike Kreiten CREW On quite a few, yes, lol. My pleasure. The joy in architectural shots or abstracts is hunting the perfect composition and light. Probably the only emotions they cause are envy and astonishment. Good enough for me, but as you know I "hunt" emotions, too, in other work. I'll proof you wrong... https://www.artsy.net/artwork/russell-james-cindy-smiling-in-bed-cindy-crawford :-) |
| Patrick Compagnucci PRO Nice work Ralph, I really enjoy your writing, and of course your photography. Warmest regards, Patrick |
![]() | Ralph Scylla CREW Thank you so much, Patrick! That really means a lot to me. I'm discovering that writing about photography can be almost as enjoyable as taking photographs — although considerably less expensive, and the models rarely complain. ;-)
Warmest wishes,
Ralph |
| Izabella Végh PRO Bellissimo articolo, come sempre. Grazie la gentile collaborazione a Tutti Voi! |
![]() | Ralph Scylla CREW Thank you, Izabella! It was a pleasure putting the photographs and music together with Yvette. I’m glad you enjoyed the article.
|
| Monica Mermoz PRO This is an excellent article! I’ve really enjoyed it.
I have rarely associated a photograph with a piece of music, but from now on, I will certainly keep that in mind much more.
Thank you Ralph and Yvette! |
![]() | Ralph Scylla CREW Thank you, Monica! I’m glad the article gave you a new way to look at photographs. If a piece of music comes to mind the next time you see a photograph you love, I’d be curious to hear what it is. |
![]() | Yvette Depaepe CREW Thanks for your appreciatyion, Monica ... Ralph did a great renewing job here! |
| Naoaki Miyamoto PRO What a wonderful initiative, Ralph and Yvette!
I think this is a very refreshing way to communicate and share how each of us sees and interprets a photograph.
The wonderful works you selected have such a richness of expression that they allow for a wide range of interpretations.
|
![]() | Ralph Scylla CREW Thank you, Naoaki. That was one of the pleasures of putting this together. Two people can look at the same photograph and hear entirely different music. Some of the photographs we chose could have had a whole playlist of their own. |
![]() | Yvette Depaepe CREW All honours go to Ralph ... Such a fine article! |
| Jane Lyons CREW Thanks for this Ralph. It's wonderfully original and appreciated very much. |
![]() | Ralph Scylla CREW Thank you, Jane. I had great fun putting this one together, and I’m glad the idea felt fresh to you. |
| Alfredo Bruzzone PRO very good idea to mix photos and music, at least all is Art!! And congrats t0 the authors |
![]() | Ralph Scylla CREW Thank you, Alfredo! I like the way you put it. It’s all art. Sometimes a piece of music makes you go back to a photograph and notice a detail you missed the first time. I’m glad you gave the photographers a shout-out, too.
|
| Yvette Depaepe CREW Great article, Ralph! I enjoyed it a lot as well as the choice of images and music. Don't forget that many of our members read the magazine but don't ever comment. I'm sure they like it a lot. Also, our articles are read through social media and by a lot of people outside the 1x community. Unfortunately, non-1x members cannot comment. Cheers, Yvette |
![]() | Ralph Scylla CREW Thank you, Yvette, for publishing the piece and for reminding me how many people read the magazine without leaving a comment. It’s lovely to think the article might reach people beyond 1x as well. I’m glad you enjoyed the pairings. Choosing them was half the fun. |
| Steven T CREW Thank you, Ralph and Yvette for another interesting article. Excellent photographs and beautiful music - some familiar, and some I did not know. |
![]() | Ralph Scylla CREW Thank you, Steven! I’m particularly pleased that you discovered some music you didn’t know before. I hope you liked it. |
| Eduardo Blanco García PRO Excellent |
![]() | Ralph Scylla CREW Thank you so much, Eduardo! At least now I know that someone has actually read the article. I was beginning to suspect I had written the world’s longest private diary entry. 😄 |